Skip to content
The Future Explorerby Benjamin Talin
Enablerstructural

Land Use & Housing

Land Use & Housing Supply

The rules that say what may be built where: how tall, how dense, how many homes on one plot. Where they are tight, more people wanting to live in a city does not bring more homes, only higher rents and longer commutes. When Auckland in New Zealand allowed more homes on most of its residential land, about twenty thousand extra were approved within five years. In most rich countries the rules stay tight, because the people who already own homes have the loudest say.

Maturity

2/ 5
measured
BasisThe tools work where they are used: Auckland's upzoning added about 22,000 permitted homes in five years. They are used in few places. Housing supply responds less than one-for-one to prices in eight of 25 OECD economies, coastal US regulation tightened after 2006, and England's approvals fell to their lowest since 2014.SourceOECD ECO/WKP(2019)59, Working Paper 1589 (Dec 2019); Hilber & Vermeulen, Economic Journal 126(591) (2016); Gyourko, Hartley & Krimmel, Journal of Urban Economics 124 (2021); Greenaway-McGrevy & Phillips, Journal of Urban Economics (2023); Glaeser & Gyourko, Journal of Economic Perspectives 32(1) (2018); Resolution Foundation (2025)Vintage2016–2026
ReadinessCapability 4Deployment 2Absorption 2Bound byincentivesTrendflat

Where it feeds in

2 megatrends in 2 forcesweakest link

Where you have already met this

In 2016 Auckland upzoned about three-quarters of its residential land. A peer-reviewed study estimates that about 22,000 more dwellings were permitted in the next five years than would have been otherwise, mostly townhouses and apartments.

If this moved

If land-use rules let homes follow demand, as of right rather than case by case, the built-environment deficit would rise a little but stay held at 2 by its other constraints, among them permitting speed and construction technology. Fertility collapse would keep its floor too: family formation still holds it.

What to watch for

Housing approvals and net additions in England, published quarterly, against the pace the government set itself. Rents in Auckland and near California's rezoned transit stations compared with similar places that did not upzone.

Not to be confused with

Construction technology. Construction technology changes how a home is built and what it costs; land use decides whether it may be built at all, and where.

What it is

Whether the rules on what may be built where let the supply of homes rise when demand rises. It covers zoning, density and height limits, minimum lot sizes and case-by-case planning consent, and it is measured by how far new building responds when prices go up.

How it works

  1. 01A plan sets what each plot may holdZoning maps fix the use, height, density and lot size allowed on every parcel.
  2. 02A project either fits or asks for consentWhere the plan allows it, building is as of right. Elsewhere the builder applies for a variance or a discretionary consent, which can be refused.
  3. 03Neighbours and councils weigh inHearings, objections and appeals give existing residents a say, and existing owners usually gain from scarcity.
  4. 04Supply responds, or prices doWhere consent is easy, rising demand brings more homes. Where it is hard, it brings higher prices and longer commutes.
  5. 05Higher levels of government can overrideNational or state law can upzone directly, as New Zealand and California have done, or set targets councils must meet.

State of play

  • Across 25 OECD economies, housing supply responds to prices significantly more than one-for-one only in Ireland, Norway, Sweden and the United States, and significantly less in eight, including France, Germany, Italy and the Netherlands; weaker responsiveness is associated with more restrictive land-use regulation (OECD Economics Department Working Paper 1589, Dec 2019).
  • Planning restrictiveness in England raises house prices: local planning refusal rates are a measured cause of higher prices (Hilber & Vermeulen, Economic Journal 126(591), 2016).
  • Land-use regulation tightened in most large coastal US markets between 2006 and 2018, and no highly regulated market deregulated significantly after the housing bust (Gyourko, Hartley & Krimmel, Journal of Urban Economics 124, 2021).
  • Auckland's 2016 upzoning of about three-quarters of its residential land led to about 22,000 more dwellings being permitted over five years than otherwise (Greenaway-McGrevy & Phillips, Journal of Urban Economics, 2023).
  • England approved 221,000 dwellings in the year to June 2025, the lowest since 2014 (Resolution Foundation, 2025); completions in 2025–26 were the lowest since 2015–16 (BCIS, 2026 - INDUSTRY-BELIEF).
  • UN-Habitat estimates that 2.8 billion people lack adequate housing (UN-Habitat, Annual Report 2024).

Why it matters

It decides whether demand for homes turns into homes or into prices. Where land-use rules are tight, a growing city raises rents instead of roofs, and the cost lands on the young, on renters and on anyone moving towards work. It is the land side of the built-environment deficit and one of the measured costs behind delayed family formation.

  • It is the 'land' in the guide's 'finance, land and permits' for the built-environment deficit.
  • It is the structural channel from housing cost to births. The OECD finds a clear negative association between fertility and housing costs, though for homeowners rising prices push the other way.
  • The capability is proven where it is used. The constraint is the consent of the people who already own homes.

What holds it back

Existing owners decide

Owners gain from scarcity and dominate local hearings; the people who would live in new homes do not yet vote there.

Local control

Most land-use decisions are made by municipalities whose voters bear the disruption and see few of the gains.

Reforms are partial

California's transit-area rezoning covers a small share of the state's land, and England's new planning law arrived with approvals already falling.

Terms

Supply elasticity
How much the number of homes built rises when prices rise by one per cent.
As of right
Building that complies with the plan and needs no discretionary approval.
Upzoning
Changing the rules to allow more homes, taller buildings or more uses on the same land.
Regulatory tax
The gap between a home's price and the cost of building it, read as the cost of rules that restrict supply.
Discretionary consent
Permission granted case by case by a planning authority, which may refuse it.

Steepens

MegatrendWeightRole
The Built-Environment Deficitlargeshared weakest link (with 7 others)
Fertility Collapsemoderateshared weakest link (with 1 other)

The gradient behaves like a sticky rubber band: it is pulled hardest toward the weakest enabler. Marginal links are shown but do not pull.

If this moved one step

Computed from the map as it stands: this score raised from 2 to 3, every other score unchanged. It is arithmetic, not a forecast.

Raised one step on its own, it lifts no megatrend's weakest link; each gradient it feeds still rises a little.

Tied as the weakest link

Here it shares the weakest spot with other enablers. Raising it alone leaves the weakest link where it is and lifts the gradient a little; the enablers it is tied with must move too.

  • Fertility Collapse2.0/5 , 2.4/5tied with Family Formation
  • The Built-Environment Deficit2.4/5 , 2.5/5tied with Biomaterials & Biofabrication, Construction Technology, Digital Twins, Family Formation, Permitting Speed, Public Procurement, Smart Cities
What if it moved?

What would change the gradient

Conditional, not predictive. No dates, no probabilities.

  1. 01Building as of right wherever the plan allows it, instead of case-by-case consent
  2. 02Higher-level override of local density limits near jobs and transit
  3. 03Sharing the gains of new building with the neighbours who bear the disruption

Common misconception

That the housing shortage is a construction-technology problem. In the most regulated markets the gap between what a home sells for and what it costs to build is the cost of the rules, not of the method. Cheaper building does not help where building is not allowed.

Talin, B. (2026). Land Use & Housing Supply. The Future Explorer, dataset v0.4.0 (2026-11-16). https://explorer.talin.digital/e/land-use-and-housing-supply/