Skip to content
The Future Explorerby Benjamin Talin
Enablerstructural

Public Procurement

How governments buy things, and whether they can buy anything new. States spend about an eighth of everything their economies produce through tenders, so their buying habits shape what gets made. The rules reward the safest bid and punish failed experiments, so the same suppliers win again. In the EU, the share of tenders that drew only a single bid nearly doubled in ten years. Better tools exist, such as Ukraine's open online tendering system, but few governments use them at scale.

Maturity

2/ 5
measured
BasisThe tools exist and are little used. Competition for EU public contracts fell, with single-bid tenders rising from 23.5% to 41.8% in a decade; European buyers spend about half the healthy share on innovative solutions; and US federal IT acquisition regressed on GAO's high-risk list. Ukraine's open e-procurement shows what the tools can do.SourceOECD, Government at a Glance 2025; European Court of Auditors, Special Report 28/2023; PwC for the European Commission (2021); GAO-25-107743 (Feb 2025); Defense Innovation Board (2023); Center for Global Development Working Paper 511 (Jun 2019)Vintage2018–2026
ReadinessCapability 4Deployment 2Absorption 2Bound byincentivesTrendflat

Where it feeds in

4 megatrends in 2 forcesweakest link

Where you have already met this

Across the EU, the share of public tenders that drew only one bid rose from 23.5% in 2011 to 41.8% in 2021, the European Court of Auditors found. A decade that included a reform meant to open procurement up ended with less competition, not more.

If this moved

If public buyers could try, iterate and switch supplier as a matter of routine, government as a service would rise a little but stay held at 2: data and datafication, digital transformation, generational turnover, managerial capability, regulatory clarity and smart cities hold it there too. Asymmetric warfare, digital sovereignty and the built-environment deficit would keep their floors.

What to watch for

The single-bid share in the European Commission's Single Market Scoreboard. How the Commission's proposed Public Procurement Act, with its new innovation procedure, fares in Parliament and Council. GAO's next high-risk rating for federal IT acquisition.

Not to be confused with

Digital transformation. Transformation is whether an organisation reorganises around new tools; procurement is whether the state is allowed and able to buy them in the first place.

What it is

Whether the state can buy what it needs to adopt something new: rules that let it try, iterate and change supplier, and buyers with the skill and the mandate to use them. Measured by competition for public contracts and by the share of public spending that goes to new solutions.

How it works

  1. 01A need is specifiedThe buyer writes down what it wants, often in such detail that only the existing solution fits.
  2. 02A tender is advertisedAbove set thresholds, EU and national law require open competition, published notices and fixed procedures.
  3. 03Bids are scoredPrice usually weighs most. New and small suppliers struggle with the paperwork and the track record demanded.
  4. 04The award can be challengedLosing bidders can appeal, so buyers prefer criteria that are easy to defend over criteria that find the best idea.
  5. 05The contract is managedFixed-scope contracts make change expensive, so projects that need to learn as they go overrun.

State of play

  • Public procurement was 12.7% of GDP and 29.9% of total government expenditure across the OECD in 2023 (OECD, Government at a Glance 2025).
  • The share of EU procurement procedures above the EU thresholds receiving a single bid rose from 23.5% in 2011 to 41.8% in 2021, and the average number of bidders fell from 5.7 to 3.2; the Court concluded that competition fell over the decade and the 2014 reform of the directives had not reversed it (European Court of Auditors, Special Report 28/2023, paragraph 36).
  • Thirty European countries spent 9.3% of their public procurement on innovative solutions in 2018, about half the 17% the study treats as healthy (PwC for the European Commission, The strategic use of public procurement for innovation in the digital economy, 2021).
  • GAO rated federal IT acquisition and management as having regressed in its 2025 high-risk update; the area has been on the list since 2015 (GAO-25-107743, Feb 2025).
  • The US Defense Innovation Board described the gap between funded prototypes and production contracts as a valley of death and called for a predictable decision timeline (Defense Innovation Board, Terraforming the Valley of Death, 2023).
  • The European Commission proposed a single Public Procurement Act to replace the three 2014 directives, with an innovation procedure and an optional European preference (COM(2026) 590, 9 Sep 2026).

Why it matters

Governments spend about an eighth of GDP through procurement across the OECD, so the way they buy shapes what gets made. When rules and incentives reward the safest bid and the most complete specification, states buy the old thing from the same supplier again, and digital services, defence innovation and public works arrive late and cost more.

  • It is the 'procurement' in the guide's 'bureaucratic culture and procurement' for government as a service.
  • It decides whether defence and digital pilots become fleets and services, the step the US Defense Innovation Board calls the valley of death.
  • At about an eighth of GDP, it is large enough to create the first market for what the state needs.

What holds it back

Blame runs one way

Buyers are audited for experiments that fail, rarely for those never tried, so they buy what is safe.

Specification lock-in

Detailed specifications describe the incumbent's product and exclude alternatives.

Fixed scope

Contracts that price every change as a variation make learning expensive.

Buyer skills

Outcome-based contracts and iterative software need technical buyers that many public bodies do not employ.

Terms

Single bidding
A tender that attracts only one offer, a common measure of weak competition.
Innovation procurement
Public buying of solutions that are new to the buyer or to the market, including research and development.
Pre-commercial procurement
A public buyer paying several firms to develop competing prototypes before buying at scale.
Framework agreement
A standing contract under which public buyers can order without a new tender each time.
Valley of death
The gap between a successful prototype and the first production contract.

Steepens

MegatrendWeightRole
Government as a Servicelargeshared weakest link (with 6 others)
Autonomous and Asymmetric Warfaremoderateshared weakest link (with 1 other)
Digital Sovereigntymoderateshared weakest link (with 3 others)
The Built-Environment Deficitmoderateshared weakest link (with 7 others)

The gradient behaves like a sticky rubber band: it is pulled hardest toward the weakest enabler. Marginal links are shown but do not pull.

If this moved one step

Computed from the map as it stands: this score raised from 2 to 3, every other score unchanged. It is arithmetic, not a forecast.

Raised one step on its own, it lifts no megatrend's weakest link; each gradient it feeds still rises a little.

Tied as the weakest link

Here it shares the weakest spot with other enablers. Raising it alone leaves the weakest link where it is and lifts the gradient a little; the enablers it is tied with must move too.

  • Autonomous and Asymmetric Warfare2.9/5 , 3.1/5tied with Geopolitical Alignment
  • Digital Sovereignty2.9/5 , 3.0/5tied with Data Backup Embassy, Geopolitical Alignment, Central Bank Digital Currency
  • Government as a Service2.5/5 , 2.6/5tied with Data & Datafication, Digital Transformation, Generational Turnover, Managerial Capability, Regulatory Clarity, Smart Cities
  • The Built-Environment Deficit2.4/5 , 2.5/5tied with Biomaterials & Biofabrication, Construction Technology, Digital Twins, Family Formation, Land Use & Housing Supply, Permitting Speed, Smart Cities
What if it moved?

What would change the gradient

Conditional, not predictive. No dates, no probabilities.

  1. 01Buying in increments under modular contracts instead of one fixed-scope award
  2. 02Pre-commercial procurement that pays several firms to compete on prototypes
  3. 03Audit rules that count a missed opportunity as well as a failed experiment

Common misconception

That the problem is mainly corruption or a lack of money. Both matter, but much of the damage comes from buyers who are blamed for a failed experiment and never for a missed one. The European Commission's benchmark found the general public sector, ministries, regions and municipalities, the most risk-averse buyer.

Talin, B. (2026). Public Procurement. The Future Explorer, dataset v0.4.0 (2026-11-16). https://explorer.talin.digital/e/public-procurement/