Skip to content
The Future Explorerby Benjamin Talin
Enablertechnological

Smart Cities

Putting sensors, data and automatic controls into a city's traffic lights, water pipes, bins, energy and public services. Single fixes often work well, such as finding leaks or timing traffic lights. Whole-city schemes have a rockier record. San Diego fitted 3,200 streetlights with sensors and cameras; the police began using them to investigate crimes, and they were switched off for three years until the city wrote rules for their use. The hardware was never the problem.

Maturity

2/ 5
measured
BasisPoint solutions work - road pricing, leak detection, signal timing. Whole-city programmes are dominated by cancellations and scale-backs, and San Diego's streetlight sensors stayed dark for three years until the city wrote rules for their use.SourceSmart Cities Dive (7 May 2020; 5 Aug 2020); Cities Today (29 Nov 2023); Griffiths & Sovacool, Energy Research & Social Science 62 (Apr 2020)Vintage2019–2023
ReadinessCapability 4Deployment 3Absorption 2Bound byincentivesTrendflat

Where it feeds in

5 megatrends in 3 forcesweakest link

Where you have already met this

From 2017 San Diego fitted 3,200 streetlights with sensors - a $30 million programme sold on parking, traffic and air quality. The police used the cameras to investigate crime. In 2020 the mayor had them switched off. The city approved a return in 2023: 500 cameras, under a surveillance ordinance and a privacy board. The hardware was never the problem.

If this moved

If cities bought outcomes rather than platforms, and gave an operating team authority to act on the data, water security - held at 2 by this entry alone - would be free to move. The built-environment deficit, government as a service and precision everything would stay at 2; construction technology, managerial capability and others hold them there too.

What to watch for

Pilots that move into a city's permanent operating budget instead of ending with the vendor subsidy. Surveillance ordinances with a public review step - the condition on which San Diego's sensors came back.

Not to be confused with

E-government. Online tax forms and licence renewals digitise paperwork; smart-city systems sit in the street and change how infrastructure runs.

What it is

The application of sensing, data and automation to urban systems - traffic, energy, water, waste and public services.

How it works

  1. 01Instrument the streetCameras, meters, air sensors and counters are fixed to lamp posts, pipes and junctions.
  2. 02Carry the readingsLow-power radio or mobile networks send small packets of data to a city platform.
  3. 03Combine the dataA platform joins feeds that departments used to keep separately.
  4. 04Act on itSoftware or staff change something - signal timing, pump pressure, a charge on a congested road.
  5. 05Govern the useRules say who may see the data and for what. Where those rules were missing, programmes stopped.

State of play

  • Sidewalk Labs withdrew from its Quayside project in Toronto on 7 May 2020, citing "unprecedented economic uncertainty" (Smart Cities Dive, 7 May 2020).
  • San Diego's 3,200 sensor-equipped streetlights, a $30 million programme begun in 2017, were switched off in 2020 pending a surveillance ordinance (Cities Today, 29 Nov 2023).
  • San Diego's police had repurposed the streetlight cameras mainly for criminal investigations, with no council-set rules on their use (Smart Cities Dive, 5 Aug 2020).
  • The city then approved 500 new streetlight cameras under its ordinance, at $3.5 million up front and $2 million a year (Cities Today, 29 Nov 2023).
  • Masdar City was planned for 50,000 residents and 40,000 commuters by 2016; completion was pushed back fourteen years, about 10% was built by 2019, and its carbon ambition was scaled back to low-carbon (Griffiths & Sovacool, Energy Research & Social Science 62, Apr 2020).

Why it matters

It is a category of enablers applied to a place rather than a technology, and its record is the clearest demonstration in this book that buying capability is not the same as changing outcomes.

  • It alone holds water security at 2.
  • It is one of several enablers holding the built-environment deficit, government as a service and precision everything at 2.
  • It is the application gap at municipal scale: the sensing works, and the decision process that should use it often does not exist.

What holds it back

Procurement buys platforms

Contracts pay for hardware and dashboards, not for changed outcomes.

Departmental silos

Transport, water and policing keep separate budgets and data, so a shared platform has no owner.

Public consent

Where rules on surveillance were missing, programmes were switched off - San Diego's for three years.

Short political cycles

Payback runs longer than the term of the politician who signs the contract.

Terms

Urban digital twin
A virtual model of a city's assets and flows, updated from live sensor data.
LoRaWAN
A low-power radio network that lets battery sensors send small readings over long distances.
Congestion charging
Charging vehicles to use busy roads at busy times, as Singapore's electronic road pricing does.
Surveillance ordinance
A local law requiring public review and council approval before a city uses surveillance technology.
Departmental silo
A city department with its own budget and data systems, which makes shared platforms hard to run.

Steepens

MegatrendWeightRole
The Built-Environment Deficitlargeshared weakest link (with 7 others)
Government as a Servicelargeshared weakest link (with 6 others)
Precision Everythingmoderateshared weakest link (with 4 others)
Water Securitymoderateweakest link
Energy Transition and Electrificationmoderate

The gradient behaves like a sticky rubber band: it is pulled hardest toward the weakest enabler. Marginal links are shown but do not pull.

If this moved one step

Computed from the map as it stands: this score raised from 2 to 3, every other score unchanged. It is arithmetic, not a forecast.

Lifts the weakest link in

Tied as the weakest link

Here it shares the weakest spot with other enablers. Raising it alone leaves the weakest link where it is and lifts the gradient a little; the enablers it is tied with must move too.

  • Government as a Service2.5/5 , 2.6/5tied with Data & Datafication, Digital Transformation, Generational Turnover, Managerial Capability, Public Procurement, Regulatory Clarity
  • Precision Everything2.7/5 , 2.8/5tied with Data & Datafication, Digital Twins, Managerial Capability, Workforce Trust
  • The Built-Environment Deficit2.4/5 , 2.5/5tied with Biomaterials & Biofabrication, Construction Technology, Digital Twins, Family Formation, Land Use & Housing Supply, Permitting Speed, Public Procurement

The gradient also rises in

What if it moved?

What would change the gradient

Conditional, not predictive. No dates, no probabilities.

  1. 01An operational team with authority to act on what is measured
  2. 02Procurement that buys outcomes rather than platforms
  3. 03Public consent obtained rather than assumed

Common misconception

That the failures were technical. The recurring failure mode is buying sensing without changing the decision process that would have used it - the application gap, at municipal scale.

Talin, B. (2026). Smart Cities. The Future Explorer, dataset v0.4.0 (2026-11-16). https://explorer.talin.digital/e/smart-cities/